Coyles Homemade Ice Cream - Bay Shore

75 Howells Road, Bay Shore, NY 11706


Coyle’s first opened its doors on Long Island in 1985, yet it is themed out to look like a classic American ice cream parlor from the 1950s! But no matter - it works so well, with the love of the nostalgia trip matched only by their peerless ice creams. This is an ice cream addict's vision of heaven with all the ice cream made on-site, offering a staggering variety of flavors and toppings.

Want to save
10% off your entire bill?

Foodie Card
BECOME A FOODIE CARD INSIDER! Join our email for exclusive deals and promotions.
Thank you for subscribing!